John Brown is among the maximum arguable figures within the historical past of america. For some he’s an ethical hero. For others, a monster.
The white abolitionist who grew to become to violence in an try to finish chattel slavery in The united states has grow to be a type of bellwether for perspectives on racial justice. Something that has ceaselessly been misplaced within the lengthy tussle over the which means of Brown, then again, is his deeply evangelical religion.
Brown testified obviously to his personal conversion, and he prayed that the ones round him would know “the grace of God via Jesus Christ.” He regularly held up the Bible because the authoritative Phrase of God, the excellent written norm through which God binds the sense of right and wrong. He prompt other people, “Be decided to grasp by way of revel in once could also be, whether or not Bible instruction is of Divine beginning or no longer,” satisfied that in the event that they examined the Scripture, they might uncover the reality.
Brown stays arguable lately. However as a white evangelical who has studied and written about his closing days, the ones who had been with him, and his non secular existence, I to find myself hoping evangelicals will rediscover him. Lets reclaim his legacy as a fervent believer who fashions a profoundly radical social ethic with out ever wavering from his company dedication to biblical authority.
This is to mention, I dream that John Brown’s soul would possibly march once more.
His try to unlock enslaved other people by way of violence failed, and he was once hanged in Virginia in 1859. However all through the battle years, it gave the impression his spirit brooded over the divided country. The playful soldier’s ditty about John Brown’s frame “a moldering within the grave” was once inexplicably taken up by way of squaddies and slaves alike—reworked right into a uncooked however rousing tune that invoked the evangelical extremist because the very spirit of liberty.
On the similar time, “John Brown” become a curse within the mouths of white Southerners and his title made white liberals blush. Certainly, a type of liberals, Julia Ward Howe, was once so get rid of by way of the abolitionist’s evangelical militancy that she conjured extra first rate lyrics for “John Brown Music.” She “mounted it,” from her point of view, with the high-minded Unitarian anthem “The Fight Hymn of the Republic.”
Even lately, there ceaselessly isn’t any center flooring on the subject of John Brown. Within the greater than 160 years since his demise, the divide between his critics and his admirers ceaselessly has fallen alongside strains of race, and now and again politics too, even though Brown has had admirers and detractors each Black and white, liberal and conservative.
Amongst white other people, Brown was once extensively disregarded by way of the early twentieth century. As American society backpedaled from the theory of Black other people changing into complete voters, Brown’s recognition couldn’t assist however decline. Whites within the North celebrated reunion with whites within the South and tacitly agreed to speak about the warriors’ honor and bravado and put aside the real problems that had separated patriots and traitors.
Slavery itself was once sentimentalized on this generation, with quite a lot of standard rhetoric and pictures of “mammies” and “piccaninnies.” Those that benefited from the gadget of white supremacy had been depicted sympathetically, whilst those that defended it had been speculated to be noble.
In the meantime Brown, who hated slavery greater than he liked his personal existence, was once portrayed as insane.
Black American citizens, however, at all times saved a spot for Brown on the desk of commemorated reminiscence. Frederick Douglass recalled how Brown was once no longer just a pal of abolition, however he gave the impression shockingly freed from the existing prejudices of the day. Many avowed white fighters of slavery, corresponding to evangelist Charles Finney, condemned the establishment whilst nonetheless insisting on racial segregation, even dividing revivals, as though it had been fallacious for Black other people to reply to the similar altar name as white other people.
One position that Brown isn’t perceived as a brother, particularly, is in evangelical historical past. I’ve but to peer one survey of Christianity in The united states that devotes house to Brown, or any account of evangelicalism that incorporates him.
In my outdated reproduction of The New Global Dictionary of the Christian Church, the access publicizes Brown’s “violent acts had been glorified by way of the abolitionist extremists,” and in a later iteration of the e book Who’s Who in Christian Historical past, he’s left out altogether. As an evangelical biographer of Brown, I consider each are a mistake.
On the time of Brown’s failed try to finish slavery by way of power, his religion was once known. Those that antagonistic slavery for biblical causes and shared Brown’s commitments to Christ and Scripture hailed him as certainly one of their very own. All over his incarceration in Virginia, he gained sympathetic letters from Calvinist clergy and laity, together with the notable Covenanter pastor Alexander Milligan, who later served as chaplain at massive to the Union troops all the way through the Civil Battle. He was once known as “A Prisoner of Jesus Christ” within the Congregational newsletter the New York Unbiased.
After his demise, Brown was once hailed in lots of sermons around the North. A kind of sermons, “Death to the Glory of God,” was once preached by way of the Wesleyan minister Luther Lee, who later on addressed a big out of doors assembly at Brown’s graveside close to Lake Placid, New York.
Possibly essentially the most outstanding reputation of the evangelical soul of John Brown comes from the world-famous preacher Charles Spurgeon. In 1860, in a while after the abolitionist was once hanged, Spurgeon wrote to The Christian Watchman & Reflector to counter rumors that he was once permitting US publishers to redact statements about slavery from his sermons to cause them to extra palatable to American readers.
Spurgeon mentioned he hadn’t addressed slavery, as a result of he was once preaching in Nice Britain the place it was once unlawful. However his place will have to be transparent: He would no longer partake of Communion with a slaveholder, and had been a slaveholder to return into his community, that guy would obtain a mark “that he would lift to his grave, if it didn’t lift him there.”
If that violent reaction reminded someone of Brown, Spurgeon had no qualms in regards to the comparability. Brown was once “immortal within the recollections of the great in England,” he wrote, including, “In my center he lives.”
John Brown
Brown gained the admiration of a few different evangelicals as neatly, together with Russell Conwell, the Baptist clergyman who based Temple College in Philadelphia and become the namesake of Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary.
Within the twentieth century, the minister Clarence E. Macartney, one of the vital major leaders with J. Gresham Machen of the conservative aspect of the fundamentalist-modernist department within the Presbyterian church, cited Brown a large number of occasions in his sermons. He even labored to keep certainly one of Brown’s jailhouse letters, giving it to Geneva School’s archival assortment.
Those evangelicals had been proper to peer Brown as certainly one of them. He was once raised in a religious Congregational house in Ohio’s Western Reserve, sat underneath the preaching ministry of a Presbyterian pastor, and was once educated within the Westminster Shorter Catechism. He professed religion in Christ at 16 years outdated. After conversion he become, as he later wrote, “ever after a company believer within the divine authenticity of the Bible” and “become very acquainted & possessed a maximum extraordinary reminiscence of its whole contents.” Certainly, biblical quotations fill virtually each web page of his correspondence.
In spite of efforts at the a part of some historians to painting him as heterodox, Brown’s Calvinism was once typical, extra influenced by way of the Puritans of yesteryear than by way of the novelties of New England Theology. What outstanding his Christianity from that of a few in The united states (then and now), was once a radical determination, as he as soon as put it, “to higher the situation of those that are at all times at the underneath hill aspect.” This activism was once deeply evangelical and deeply formed by way of his theological ideals.
Writing of his formative years, Brown recalled how he had witnessed a white guy beating a Black kid with an iron shovel. He mentioned he may just no longer assist however ask himself if God was once no longer additionally the daddy of the sufferer of that atrocious violence. His solution was once sure, and that formed the remainder of his existence.
As a young person, Brown in brief regarded as learning for the ministry in New England, however an asymmetric number one training and persistent irritation of his eyes discouraged those aspirations. But his dedication to Christian religion by no means wavered. That is in all probability maximum obviously noticed in his relationships together with his kids, a number of of whom rejected Christianity as younger adults.
When his namesake declared himself a spiritualist in 1853, Brown dashed off a six-page excursion de power of Scriptures, from Previous to New Testomony, together with Jeremiah’s enchantment, “Flip, O backsliding kids saith the Lord.” To some other apostate son, Brown wrote, “I don’t really feel ‘estranged from my kids,’ however I will not flatter them, nor ‘cry peace when there is not any peace.’”
After embarking on his antislavery marketing campaign in 1857, he gave a Bible to his youngest daughter, Ellen. Inside of he wrote, “Would possibly the Holy Spirit of God incline your center in earliest infancy to obtain the reality within the love of it and to manipulate your ideas, phrases and movements by way of its smart and holy precepts.”
Any other position Brown’s evangelical sentiments come via obviously is the phrases he wrote in his closing days. After being sentenced to demise, he wrote to his sisters, “Are you able to consider it imaginable that the scaffold has no terrors on your personal deficient, outdated unworthy brother? I thank God via Jesus Christ my Lord it’s even so.”
Two days earlier than he was once hanged, Brown wrote an extended letter to his circle of relatives, stating how he were “travailing in delivery” for them, praying that none would “fail of the grace of God via Jesus Christ, that no person of you can be unaware of the reality.” Urging them to absorb the Scriptures as their “day by day & nightly learn about,” he appealed that they wouldn’t depend on their “personal obscure theories framed up” as an alternative of the Phrase of God.
“Oh,” he appealed, “don’t believe your everlasting all upon the boisterous Ocean with out even a Helm or Compass to enable you to in steerage.”
Brown was once pressured by way of his forthcoming demise to imagine whether or not the plan to absorb fingers to wreck slavery were a mistake. Had he failed? To reply to, he grew to become once more to religion.
“I consider maximum firmly that God reigns,” he wrote to a priest from demise row. “I will not consider that the rest I’ve executed, suffered or might but endure, will probably be misplaced to the reason for God or of humanity. … I now really feel completely reconciled to that … for God’s plan was once infinitely higher.”
One might, in fact nonetheless query Brown’s ways and the best way he put his religion into motion in “Bleeding Kansas” and the raid on Harpers Ferry. I believe the proof displays that he was once no longer pushed, as has so ceaselessly been alleged, by way of crazed bloodlust or violent megalomania.
Certainly, Brown was once in reality “averse to the useless losing of blood,” in step with a New York Instances account from the time, and ordered his raiders to workout nice care lest blameless civilians be harmed. The one antislavery reporter to hide the abolitionist’s closing days, an undercover journalist for the New York Tribune, characterised Brown’s plan because the “rescue of an ideal collection of slaves,” arguing he had no real interest in keeping up “a warlike place in Virginia for any particular time period.”
When a jury of slaveholders discovered him accountable of rebel, Brown rejected it, stating in courtroom that he had no such goal. One in all his sons claimed that the purpose with the raid was once to not kill white slaveholders and spark a violent rebellion, however “open the best way for slaves in expanding numbers to flee from their masters.” Brown was hoping that, given a possibility, other people in bondage would flee. If sufficient of them did, that will “render slavery unsure and unprofitable.”
The primary draft of historical past, then again, was once most commonly written by way of the proslavery press. The preliminary interpretation of Brown’s movements was once crafted by way of individuals who believed that “all males are created equivalent” was once a lie.
I’ve discovered that a lot of the actual tale of John Brown has thus been misplaced to cartoon and partisan interpretation, a selective studying of historical past that withholds the similar concerns ceaselessly granted to different figures in Christian historical past.
Possibly we would possibly rethink the phrases of Preston Jones, who as soon as wrote in CT: “As a result of Christian readers, writers, or lecturers of historical past know that sin infects the whole lot, they can workout charity, compassion, and working out towards ancient figures who made huge mistakes.”
After all, I don’t consider John Brown’s “mistakes” had been “huge” compared to white Christians who secured the shackles of the slave, fought to suppress local peoples, and enforced racial oppression. However I do assume shall we ask ourselves why Brown can not a minimum of obtain the similar charity that evangelicals have prolonged to others who had been, as they are saying, “males in their time.”
In our time, white evangelicals appear to be in dire want of excellent examples of people that had been reworked by way of their religion to upward push above pedestrian racism—as a result of, no longer regardless of, their unshakable dedication to the authority of Scripture. Why no longer John Brown? Why no longer essentially the most esteemed white guy in Black historical past?
“Anyplace there’s a proper factor to be executed,” Brown preferred to mention, “there’s a ‘thus saith the Lord’ that it can be executed.”
Indisputably that’s a spirit that are supposed to cross marching on.
Louis A. DeCaro Jr. is professor of Christian historical past and theology at Alliance Theological Seminary and the writer of a number of books on John Brown. He additionally hosts the podcast John Brown Lately.
To free up this newsletter on your buddies, use any of the social percentage buttons on our web site, or just reproduction the hyperlink underneath.
To percentage this newsletter with your folks, use any of the social percentage buttons on our web site, or just reproduction the hyperlink underneath.

supply